메뉴 건너뛰기
Library Notice
Institutional Access
If you certify, you can access the articles for free.
Check out your institutions.
ex)Hankuk University, Nuri Motors
Log in Register Help KOR
Subject
Humanities
General Humanities History Philosophy Religious Studies Linguistics and Literature Other Humanities
Social science
General Social Science Business Management Tourism Education Military Science Library and Information Science Law Sociology Journalism and Media Studies Psychological Science Political Science and Diplomacy Geography Public Administration Economics International Trade Anthropology Other Social Science
Natural science
General Natural Science Physics Biology Life Sciences Mathematics/Statistics Astronomy Earth Science Chemistry Other Natural Science
Engineering
General Engineering Architectural Engineering Mechanical Engineering Industrial Engineering Material/Energy Engineering Electrical and Electronic Engineering Marine and Ocean Engineering Chemical Engineering Computer Science Other Engineering
Medical science
General Medical Science Nursing Science Veterinary Pharmacy Traditional Korean Medicine Basic Medicine Clinical Medicine Other Medicine
Agriculture and Fishery
General Agriculture and Fishery Agriculture Fishery Science Food Science Forestry Animal Husbandry Marine Transportation Studies Other Agriculture and Fishery
Art and Kinesiology
General Arts Design Fine Arts Cosmetology Photography Music Fashion Kinesiology Performing Media Arts Other Arts and Kinesiology
Interdisciplinary Studies
Interdisciplinary Research Science and Technology Studies Brain and Cognitive Science Technology Policy Other Interdisciplinary Studies

KOR

Is Reflective Equilibrium compatible with Foundationalism?
Recommendations
Search

반성적 평형은 토대주의와 양립가능한가?

논문 기본 정보

Type
Academic journal
Author
CHOI Kyungsuk (이화여자대학교)
Journal
Korean Society of Ethics 윤리학 윤리학 제9권 제1호 KCI Candidated Journals
Published
2020.1
Pages
29 - 57 (29page)

Usage

cover
Is Reflective Equilibrium compatible with Foundationalism?
Ask AI
Recommendations
Search

Abstract· Keywords

Report Errors
The method of reflective equilibrium, whether it is wide or narrow, has usually been understood as a coherentist moral reasoning and justification. However, R. M. Hare and Peter Singer hold that the method of reflective equilibrium is committed to foundationalism because it is committed to intuitionism. Michael R. De Paul claims that the methods of wide and narrow reflective equilibrium while not committed to foundationalism, are compatible with it. I agree with De Paul’s argument that there is no necessary relation between the method of reflective equilibrium and foundationalism and that both are compatible. Tom L. Beauchamp and James F. Childress support and adopt reflective equilibrium as a method for biomedical ethics, but introduce considered moral judgments of common morality as foundation in order to solve the problem of pirates’Creed. Although Beauchamp and Childress support the method of reflective equilibrium, they do not want to be called as a coherentist. Their position can be called a moderate foundationalism such as Robert Audi explained because it allows coherence for justification. But I argue that Beauchamp and Childress’ solution is not the only one to solve the problem of Pirates’Creed, and that they do not discern wide reflective equilibrium from narrow reflective equilibrium. Thus, they thought that the need of substantial moral norm may be satisfied by the introduction of foundational beliefs. Rawls’s reflective equilibrium is not compatible with foundationalism because he kept the principle of coherentism that considered moral judgments may be revised for coherence. Beauchamp and Childress did not success in proving that their foundationalism is an alternative to coherentist’s reflective equilibrium because they did not prove that considered moral judgments of common morality are foundational beliefs.
#반성적 평형 #정합주의 #토대주의 #숙고된 도덕 판단

Contents

No content found

References (0)

Add References
If the reference is being serviced by DBpia, please register through [Add Reference]

Recommendations

It is an article recommended by DBpia according to the article similarity. Check out the related articles!

Related Authors

Recently viewed articles

Gallstone ileus inducing obstructive jaundice at the afferent loop of Roux-en-Y hepaticojejunostomy after bile duct cancer surgery
Hyun Gu Lee, Shin Hwang, Yo-Han Joo 외 2명The Korean Association of HBP Surgery2015.05
 Information Dispersal Algorithm and Proof of Ownership for Data Deduplication in Dispersed Storage Systems
Youngjoo ShinKorea Institute Of Information Security And Cryptology2015.02
 The Effects of the Brand Value of the Winning Traditional Liquor Competition on Brand Image, Brand Attitude, and Purchase Intention
Young Kyung Jeong, Jae Youn KoCulinary Society of Korea2021.03
 [테마기획 : 생체모방공학] 생체모방형 인공근육의 구동
이석민The Korean Society of Mechanical Engineers2006.04

Comments(0)

0

Write first comments.