메뉴 건너뛰기
Library Notice
Institutional Access
If you certify, you can access the articles for free.
Check out your institutions.
ex)Hankuk University, Nuri Motors
Log in Register Help KOR
Subject
Humanities
General Humanities History Philosophy Religious Studies Linguistics and Literature Other Humanities
Social science
General Social Science Business Management Tourism Education Military Science Library and Information Science Law Sociology Journalism and Media Studies Psychological Science Political Science and Diplomacy Geography Public Administration Economics International Trade Anthropology Other Social Science
Natural science
General Natural Science Physics Biology Life Sciences Mathematics/Statistics Astronomy Earth Science Chemistry Other Natural Science
Engineering
General Engineering Architectural Engineering Mechanical Engineering Industrial Engineering Material/Energy Engineering Electrical and Electronic Engineering Marine and Ocean Engineering Chemical Engineering Computer Science Other Engineering
Medical science
General Medical Science Nursing Science Veterinary Pharmacy Traditional Korean Medicine Basic Medicine Clinical Medicine Other Medicine
Agriculture and Fishery
General Agriculture and Fishery Agriculture Fishery Science Food Science Forestry Animal Husbandry Marine Transportation Studies Other Agriculture and Fishery
Art and Kinesiology
General Arts Design Fine Arts Cosmetology Photography Music Fashion Kinesiology Performing Media Arts Other Arts and Kinesiology
Interdisciplinary Studies
Interdisciplinary Research Science and Technology Studies Brain and Cognitive Science Technology Policy Other Interdisciplinary Studies

KOR

Error Theory, Fictionalism, and the Objectivity of Moral Institution
Recommendations
Search
Questions

오류이론, 허구론, 그리고 도덕체계의 객관성

논문 기본 정보

Type
Academic journal
Author
Hoayoung Youn (평택대학교)
Journal
Korean Philosophical Association Korean Journal of Philosophy Vol.133 KCI Excellent Accredited Journal
Published
2017.11
Pages
103 - 128 (26page)
DOI
10.18694/KJP.2017.11.133.103

Usage

cover
📌
Topic
📖
Background
🔬
Method
🏆
Result
Error Theory, Fictionalism, and the Objectivity of Moral Institution
Ask AI
Recommendations
Search
Questions

Abstract· Keywords

Report Errors
This article discusses problems with John Mackie’s error theory and Richard Joyce’s fictionalism which is grounded in the former theory. Although Mackie denies all the “objective” moral values, he admits that a human society can have a moral institution, by which moral cognitivism is actually possible. Richard Joyce proposes fictionalism, according to which, all moral values and institution in our moral experiences are not real; all moral judgments are “false,” and moral belief should be abandoned. Nevertheless moral institution in actual life should be maintained, he argues, because it gives us some benefit. The author explains and criticizes each theory. According to the fictionalism, moral institution is an illusion. It can mean that it has no authority or persuasiveness to exhort people to carry out moral conducts. So it would be completely incompetent when people prefer chasing their own interests to observing moral norms. Similarly, it cannot mediate moral disagreements. For these reasons, the fictionalism hardly shows, the author argues, that moral institution stands on a stable ground. Mackie’s theory would be a bit better in showing the institution’s stability, thanks to the notion of subjective moral sentiment. But since the error theory rejects moral objectivity and all “objective” values, the author argues, Mackie’s theory would be caught in the same problem.
#오류이론 #허구론 #객관성 #도덕체계 #두 단계의 도덕적 사고 #error theory #fictionalism #moral objectivity #moral institution #two levels of moral thought

Contents

【요약문】
1. 머릿말
2. 맥키의 오류이론과 세 가지 개념의 객관성
3. 허구론과 보존론
4. 허구론의 문제들
5. 두 단계 사고의 분리와 일상적 도덕체계
6. 맺는말
참고문헌
Abstract

References (18)

Add References
[학술지(정기간행물)] - 윤화영 / 2006 / Non-cognitivism의 바른 평가 / 철학연구 (32) : 199 ~ 224 google schola [학술지(정기간행물)] - 윤화영 / 2016 / 도덕가치의 보편화와 도덕 상대주의 / 철학연구 (115) : 419 ~ 443 dbpia [단행본] - Blackburn, Simon. / 1993 / Essays in Quasi-Realism / Oxford University Press google schola [단행본] - Evans, M. / 2012 / Moral Agency and Metaethics : 80 ~ 109 google schola [단행본] - Garner, Richard. / 2010 / A World Without Values: Essays on John Makcie’s Moral Error Theory : 217 ~ 233 google schola

Recommendations

It is an article recommended by DBpia according to the article similarity. Check out the related articles!

Related Authors

Frequently Viewed Together

Nonconceptual Content and Phenomenal Consciousness
Woo Jin Han Journal of The Society of philosophical studies 2009 .03
Theodicy Debate in Anthony Flew, John L. Mackie, John Hick and Alvin Plantinga
Jangsaeng Kim Theological Studies 2018 .06
Can emergence contribute to solving the traditional problems of free will?
Hong ,  Ji-Ho Journal of the New Korean Philosophical Association 2018 .04
신념의 논리 : 알빈 플란팅가의 "신념의 기본성" 문제
배국원 복음과 실천 1994 .09
Universalizability of Moral Values and Moral Relativism
Hoayoung Youn Journal of The Society of philosophical studies 2016 .12

Recently viewed articles

우리 대학의 신자유주의적 추세에 대한 비판적 고찰
박찬구philculture2018.12
 A Study on the Young People"s Psychological wellbeing of Popular Songs : Focusing on the Idol Music
Yong-Seon Cho, In-Hee ChoThe Korean Entertainment Industry Association2014.11
 Legal and institutional limitations of the self-governing police system and improvement measures
Hwang, MUNGYUKorean Association For Local Government Studies2022.09

Comments(0)

0

Write first comments.