메뉴 건너뛰기
.. 내서재 .. 알림
소속 기관/학교 인증
인증하면 논문, 학술자료 등을  무료로 열람할 수 있어요.
한국대학교, 누리자동차, 시립도서관 등 나의 기관을 확인해보세요
(국내 대학 90% 이상 구독 중)
로그인 회원가입 고객센터 ENG
주제분류
인문학
인문학 일반 역사학 철학 종교학 어문학 기타 인문학
사회과학
사회과학 일반 경영학 관광학 교육학 군사학 문헌정보학 법학 사회학 신문방송학 심리과학 정치외교학 지리학 행정학 경제학 무역학 인류학 기타 사회과학
자연과학
자연과학 일반 물리학 생물학 생활과학 수학·통계학 천문학 지구과학 화학 기타 자연과학
공학
공학 일반 건축공학 기계공학 산업공학 재료·에너지공학 전기전자공학 조선해양공학 화학공학 컴퓨터학 기타공학
의약학
의학 일반 간호학 수의학 약학 한의학 기초의학 임상의학 기타 의약학
농수해양학
농수해양학 일반 농학 수산학 식품과학 임학 축산학 해상운송학 기타 농수해양학
예술체육학
예술 일반 디자인 미술 미용 사진 음악학 의상 체육 공연매체예술 기타 예술체육학
복합학
학제간연구 과학기술학 뇌인지과학 기술정책 기타 복합학

ENG

추천
검색

논문 기본 정보

자료유형
학술저널
저자정보
저널정보
중국어문연구회 중국어문논총 중국어문논총 제80호
발행연도
2017.1
수록면
1 - 26 (26page)

이용수

표지
📌
연구주제
📖
연구배경
🔬
연구방법
🏆
연구결과
AI에게 요청하기
추천
검색

초록· 키워드

오류제보하기
This paper adduces philological evidence to support a new interpretation of a long-controversial passage in “Weizheng(為政)” in The Analects, which reads 子游問孝. 子曰: “今之孝者, 是謂能養. 至於犬馬, 皆能有養. 不敬, 何以別乎?” (Ziyou asked about filial piety. The Confucius said: “Filial piety nowadays means to be able to tend. Even dogs and horses can all have the case of tending/being tended. If one does not respect, by what means can one distinguish?”) There has been disagreement regarding the agent and patient in 至於犬馬皆能有養(Even dogs and horses can all have the case of tending/being tended). There are three possible interpretations: (1) 人養犬馬 “The human beings tend dogs and horses” (2) 犬馬養人 “Dogs and horses tend the human beings” (養 is the falling tone) (3) 犬馬養犬馬 “Dogs and horses tend their own parents” (養 is the falling tone) This paper aims to strengthen the third interpretation, 犬馬養犬馬 (Dogs and horses tend their own parents). This interpretation was suggested by Qing dynasty scholars, including Li, Guangdi 李光地 and Zhai, Hao 翟灝. Li paraphrased the passage as 蓋言禽獸亦能相養, 但無禮耳; 人養親而不敬, 何以自別於禽獸乎?(It roughly means that birds and beasts can also tend each other. It is just that they do not have the proper ritual. If human beings tend their parents, yet do not respect, by what means can they distinguish themselves from birds and beasts?) Zhai also pointed out a very similar passage in “Fangji” 坊記 in Liji(禮記): 子云: “小人皆能養其親. 君子不敬, 何以辨?”(The Confucious said: “Even the petty men can all tend their parents. If the gentleman does not respect, by what means can one distinguish?”) The passage in Liji contains 犬馬 “dogs and horses” where The Analect has 小人 “petty men” and it explicitly expresses the object of 養 ‘to tend’, which is 其親 ‘one’s parents’; the rest is extremely similar, and the gist of the two passages is identical. This paper argues that the 犬馬養犬馬(Dogs and horses tend their own parents) interpretation is plausible based on the following three facts. First, given that both The Analect and Liji are Confucianists’ texts, the occurrence of the parallel passage noted above is not accidental at all. Rather, it implies that the idea was popular among Confucianists. Second, Confucianists’ texts often discuss the idea that there are different levels of 孝 ‘filial piety’. For instance, a passage in “Zaji shang” 雜記上 in Liji(禮記), which reads　曾子曰: “孝有三：大孝尊親，其次弗辱，其下能養” (Zengzi said: “There are three levels of filial piety. The highest is to respect one’s parents. Next is not to offend them. The lowest level is to be able to tend them.”) stresses that tending is merely the lowest level of filial piety, where that of the highest level must include respect. Third, in Classical Chinese texts, animals are often personalized in order to highlight the extreme appropriateness of human beings’ behaving in a certain way. The passage 鳥獸之於不義, 尚知避之, 況於人乎!(Even birds and beast know to avoid injustice. How much is it even more so in case of human beings?) in Kongzi jiayu(孔子家語) is an example. In sum, 至於犬馬, 皆能有養. 不敬, 何以別乎? in The Analect should be interpreted as “Even if dogs and horses tend their own parents: If one does not respect [one’s parents], by what means can one differentiate the filial piety of animals [which only contains tending] and that of human beings [which must contain both tending and respect]?”
#he Analects #all......) #upto) #y?ng/yang #the high tend the low/the low tend the high)

목차

등록된 정보가 없습니다.

참고문헌 (27)

참고문헌 신청
/ / Chinese Text Project google schola / / 中央?究院漢語電子文獻古漢語語料庫 google schola / 1998 / 校正宋本廣韻 / 藝文印書館 google schola / 2013 / 經典釋文 / 上海古籍出版社 google schola Baxter, William, H. / 1992 / A Handbook of Old Chinese Phonology / Mouton de Gruyter google schola

함께 읽어보면 좋을 논문

논문 유사도에 따라 DBpia 가 추천하는 논문입니다. 함께 보면 좋을 연관 논문을 확인해보세요!

이 논문의 저자 정보

최근 본 자료

전체보기

댓글(0)

0