메뉴 건너뛰기
Library Notice
Institutional Access
If you certify, you can access the articles for free.
Check out your institutions.
ex)Hankuk University, Nuri Motors
Log in Register Help KOR
Subject
Humanities
General Humanities History Philosophy Religious Studies Linguistics and Literature Other Humanities
Social science
General Social Science Business Management Tourism Education Military Science Library and Information Science Law Sociology Journalism and Media Studies Psychological Science Political Science and Diplomacy Geography Public Administration Economics International Trade Anthropology Other Social Science
Natural science
General Natural Science Physics Biology Life Sciences Mathematics/Statistics Astronomy Earth Science Chemistry Other Natural Science
Engineering
General Engineering Architectural Engineering Mechanical Engineering Industrial Engineering Material/Energy Engineering Electrical and Electronic Engineering Marine and Ocean Engineering Chemical Engineering Computer Science Other Engineering
Medical science
General Medical Science Nursing Science Veterinary Pharmacy Traditional Korean Medicine Basic Medicine Clinical Medicine Other Medicine
Agriculture and Fishery
General Agriculture and Fishery Agriculture Fishery Science Food Science Forestry Animal Husbandry Marine Transportation Studies Other Agriculture and Fishery
Art and Kinesiology
General Arts Design Fine Arts Cosmetology Photography Music Fashion Kinesiology Performing Media Arts Other Arts and Kinesiology
Interdisciplinary Studies
Interdisciplinary Research Science and Technology Studies Brain and Cognitive Science Technology Policy Other Interdisciplinary Studies

KOR

Animal Experiment and Deliberation
Recommendations
Search
Questions

동물실험과 심의

논문 기본 정보

Type
Academic journal
Author
Journal
Korean Philosophical Association Korean Journal of Philosophy Vol.92 KCI Excellent Accredited Journal
Published
2007.8
Pages
231 - 256 (26page)

Usage

DBpia Top 0.5%Percentile based on 2-year
usage in the same subject category.
cover
📌
Topic
📖
Background
🔬
Method
🏆
Result
Animal Experiment and Deliberation
Ask AI
Recommendations
Search
Questions

Abstract· Keywords

Report Errors
This article deals with animal experiment in terms of deliberative theory. Firstly, it outlines the arguments for and against animal experiment, and then examines the moral standing of animals in views of Habermas and Rawls who are outstanding theorists in the camp of deliberative democracy. In doing so, we expect that we catch the implicit features of deliberative theory. It is important that animals as well as humans are sentient beings and higher animals have the ability of self-consciousness. Animals should be treated differently from inanimate beings. However, Regan and Singer overemphasize the standing of animals. In reality, it is impossible for us to respect the inherent worth of animals and to put the principle of equal consideration of interests into practice. As Habermas and Rawls see, morality is only the social constructions which humans make for social cooperation. We meet the dilemma around moral motivation, "Why should we be moral?", if we adhere to the principles of Regan and Singer in the extreme.
Animals are not instrumental beings for human and at the same time, it is not wrong of us to discriminate against animals on the ground of species. We should respect animals at the level of which we can secure our survival and the development of our civilization. In this context, we should avoid animal experiment as possible, but it can be justifiable unless we have any alternative. In this case, we should make efforts to reduce the suffering of animals. We agree to 3R principles: reduction, refinement, and replacement.
#동물실험 #동물해방 #동물권리 #3R #심의민주주의 #하버마스 #롤즈 #Animal Experiment #Animal Liberation #Animal Right #3R #Deliberative Democracy #Habermas #Rawls

Contents

【요약문】
1. 연구배경
2. 동물실험 논쟁
3. 하버마스와 동물실험
4. 롤주와 동물
5. 보편주의, 계약주의, 진화론
6. 결론
【참고문헌】
〈Abstract〉

References (21)

Add References
2. [학술지(정기간행물)] - 김진석 / 2001 / 동물이용연구윤리 과학연구윤리 google schola 3. [학술지(정기간행물)] - 남유철 / 2005 / 개를 위한 변명 google schola 4. [학술지(정기간행물)] - 박창길 / 2005 / 동물윤리와 한국의 동물보호법 개정 / 환경철학 (4) : 29 ~ 72 google schola 5. [학술지(정기간행물)] - 최경석 / 2004 / 생명의료윤리를 위한 도덕적 추론으로서의 넓은 반성적 평형의 방법 (60) google schola 6. [학술지(정기간행물)] - Carruthers / 1992 / Moral theory in practice google schola

Recommendations

It is an article recommended by DBpia according to the article similarity. Check out the related articles!

Related Authors

Frequently Viewed Together

국내 학술 문헌에서 논의된 동물실험의 찬성과 반대
구영모 한국실험동물학회 학술발표대회 논문집 2010 .02
동물실험은 윤리적으로 옹호 가능한가?
최훈 한국실험동물학회 학술발표대회 논문집 2016 .02
생명존중문화를 위한 국내 동물실험윤리의 한계와 전망
박창길 한국실험동물학회 학술발표대회 논문집 2016 .02
Claims for Animal Right and Ethical Consideration on Primate Experiments
Jung-Wan Choo ,  Kyung-Suk Choi ,  Ivo Kwon Journal of the Korean Bioethics Association 2007 .06
개정 동물보호법과 동물실험 제도
Yeom-Soon Choi 한국실험동물학회 학술발표대회 논문집 2007 .11

Recently viewed articles

A Structural Relationship between Young Children`s Happiness and its Variables: Temperament, Parenting Efficacy and Ego-Resilience
Choe Sun-mi, Choi Mi-sookThe Korean Society for Early Childhood Teacher Education2016.08
 A study on the growth of elementary pre-service teachers’ teaching skills through online English microteaching
sun leeundefined2021
 A Study on the Deactivation Causes of the Dry Sorbents Using Ca-based Materials
Hu In Kang, Min Sun Cho, Ho Jin Chae 외 5명Korea Society of Energy&Climate Change2019.05
 The Authenticity of Sign Language as Perceived by Deaf and Hearing People: Discovering Identity Through Communication
Hong-Im Shinundefined2024.08

Comments(0)

0

Write first comments.

UCI(KEPA) : I410-ECN-0101-2009-105-018886887