Human Nature and the Principle of Justice : Focusing on Cicero's De Legibus Book 1 :Focusing on Cicero’s De Legibus Book 1

Jung Hun Shim

Human Nature and the Principle of Justice : Focusing on Cicero's De Legibus Book 1

Recommendations

Search

Questions

Type: Academic journal

Author: Jung Hun Shim (Seoul National University)

Journal: The Korean Society of Greco-Roman Studies The Journal of Greco-Roman Studies Vol.57 No.3 KCI Accredited Journals

Published: 2018.12

Pages: 81 - 107 (27page)

Usage

📌

Topic

📖

Background

🔬

Method

🏆

Result

Human Nature and the Principle of Justice : Focusing on Cicero's De Legibus Book 1

Abstract· Keywords

Report Errors

This paper aims to examine the content and strive to demonstrate the coherence of book 1 of Cicero’s De Legibus. The overall structure of the work is approached from the objective set forth by Cicero himself; namely seeking out the nature of justice from the nature of man. Cicero seems to hold a high view of justice, which needs the highest law for its justification. Cicero directly repudiates Atticus’ Epicurean theological stance as an unsuitable foundation for justice. In opposition to the assessment that denounces the appropriateness of the discourse on the gods, I refer to Cicero’s other philosophical works to demonstrate its relevance to the topic of justice. Binding human nature to the celestial beings greatly elevates human moral standards, and sharply distinguishes him from the rest of the creatures bound to inferior animal instinct. This understanding of human nature forms the bedrock for arguing that justice is by nature (ius esse natura). The problem with such ideal was that it failed to reflect the undeniable facts of reality. It was evident that customs differed depending on location and time and sacrificing one’s wealth or life for justice seemed unnatural and foolish. Cicero was fully aware of these objections. I demonstrate some of the challenges Cicero might have faced by comparing our passage with Carneades’ infamous lectures reenacted in book 3 of De Republica and suggest some countermeasures that Cicero might have raised against these attacks. The ultimate response to these objections is to denounce them as a distortion of the true human nature. I claim that the whole point of expanding the discussion from justice to virtue and then to summum bonum was Cicero’s way of setting forth his idea of the ultimate end of human life. Attainment of wisdom is the end of men, the pursuit of which is encouraged by philosophy. The injunction to “know yourself” is the crux of philosophy, which is a cry to understand the divine nature implanted in oneself. In analyzing the tripartite philosophy in the encomium of wisdom, I refer to Cicero’s Tusculanae Disputationes and Scipio’s Dream to demonstrate once again the divine and eternal nature of men. I conclude that the seemingly diverse and loosely connected topics in book 1 of De Legibus coherently encompass the whole nature of men from its divine inception to its eternal termination, and that this sublime nature is uniquely qualified as a foundation for Cicero’s conception of justice.

#Cicero #De Legibus #human nature #justice #reason

1. Principles of Justice : Human Nature as the Foundation of Justice
2. Refuting the Unnaturalness of Justice : Comparison with De Republica Book 3
3. Perfection of Human Nature : Summum Bonum and the Injunction to “Know Yourself”
4. Conclusion
Bibliography
Abstract

References (0)

Add References

If the reference is being serviced by DBpia, please register through [Add Reference]

Recommendations

It is an article recommended by DBpia according to the article similarity. Check out the related articles!

Related Authors

Jung Hun Shim

Affiliation Seoul National University

Fields Humanities > Linguistics and Literature > Other Linguistics and Literature

Articles 1 Usage 40

Frequently Viewed Together

Ten Legal Cases in Cicero’s De oratore 1.175-184 : Examples of Famous Historical Trials or of School Theseis and Controversiae?

Ba , tosz Awianowicz The Journal of Greco-Roman Studies 2015 .12

Comments(0)

Write first comments.

UCI(KEPA) : I410-ECN-0101-2019-800-000330580

구분	그룹	데이터 항목
AI 학습용 데이터	원문	원문 PDF 파일
AI 학습용 데이터	원문 + 메타 (기본/상세)	원문 PDF 파일 및 서지정보 CSV
대량 구매용 데이터	B2B 구독 방식	특정 자료 한정으로 원문 접근 권한 부여
대량 구매용 데이터	URL 전달 방식	바로 PDF 뷰어를 열람할 수 있는 URL 제공

구분	그룹	데이터 항목
AI 학습용 데이터	기본 메타	발행기관명, 간행물명, 권호명, 권(vol), 호(issue), 통권, 발행연도, 발행월, 논문명, 저자명, 시작페이지, 종료페이지, 전체페이지, 상세페이지URL
상세 메타 데이터	발행기관 메타	발행기관 이명, 영문명, 창립연도, 홈페이지URL, 발행기관 소개
	간행물 메타	부제목, 간행물 유형, ISSN, ISBN, 최초발행연도, 폐간연도, 간행빈도, 발행주기, 등재사항, 이용수, 피인용수, 권호수, 논문수, 표지이미지
	논문 메타	작성 언어, 부제목, 대등제목, 목차, 키워드, 초록, 이미지, 참고문헌, 이용수, 피인용수, 논문활용도, DBpia통합주제분류, KDC분류, DDC분류, 한국연구재단분류, UCI, DOI
	저자 메타	소속기관, 소속부서, 직급, 연구분야, 연구키워드, 이용수, 피인용수, 저자 논문활용도

구분	그룹	데이터 항목
※ 결합형/맞춤형 메타 데이터는 신청 내용에 따라 다양하게 제공 가능
이용순위 정보	주제분야별 많이 이용된 논문	“인문학”에서 많이 이용된 논문 TOP100
	이용기관별 많이 이용된 논문	“중고등학교”에서 많이 이용된 논문 TOP100
	세부기관별 많이 이용된 논문	“서울대학교”에서 많이 이용된 논문 TOP100
	키워드별 많이 이용된 논문	“Chat GPT”에서 많이 이용된 논문 TOP100
키워드 정보	많이 이용된 키워드	특정기간/분야/저널 내 많이 이용된 키워드
	많이 발행된 키워드	특정기간/분야/저널 내 많이 발행된 키워드
	많이 검색된 키워드	특정기간/분야/저널 내 많이 검색된 키워드
	연구 트렌드 키워드	특정 키워드 연관 연구동향 분석 데이터 키워드

논문 기본 정보

Abstract· Keywords

AI Summary

Topic

Background

Method

Result

주요내용

Contents

References (0)

Recommendations

Related Authors

Frequently Viewed Together

Recently viewed articles

Comments(0)