지원사업
학술연구/단체지원/교육 등 연구자 활동을 지속하도록 DBpia가 지원하고 있어요.
커뮤니티
연구자들이 자신의 연구와 전문성을 널리 알리고, 새로운 협력의 기회를 만들 수 있는 네트워킹 공간이에요.
초록· 키워드
오류제보하기
It is widely said that Korea is similar to Ireland. However, this statement is very vague since the assumed similarities between the two countries have never been specified; specification might lead to an articulation of a Korean national identity. This paper confronts this statement and investigates Yanaihara Tadao's articles on the two countries which have been influential in defining their national identities.
Yanaihara is a prominent Japanese scholar of colonial policies who has written that Korea is "Japan's Ireland." While writing with the aim of learning lessons from Japanese colonial rule, he devoted only one paragraph to the "Irish question" by making an analogy between Irish-British and Korean-Japanese relations. Therefore his analogy is a very limited, and moreover, a forced one, since he makes the historically-false and pro-imperial statement that Korea voluntarily maintained a close economic and military relationship with Japan.
Yanaihara's articles on Korea in the 1920s strongly criticized the repressiveness of the Japanese colonial law and proposed the establishment of a colonial parliament. While his proposal was one of the most liberal, it contained several shortcomings. First, it was unrealistic, considering the weakness of the Japanese parliament itself. Second, he ignored the lesson learned from Irish history that showed that a colonial parliament could not solve colonial discontent.
Here the foundation of Yanaihara's analogy between Korea and Ireland crumbles, since in addition to, or because of, the strain it put on facts regarding the two countries. Therefore it did not lead to a better policy for Korea. When Yanaihara's views are brought up in conjunction with the statement that Korea and Ireland are similar, we must remember that his views are an artifact of the Japanese colonial era.
Yanaihara is a prominent Japanese scholar of colonial policies who has written that Korea is "Japan's Ireland." While writing with the aim of learning lessons from Japanese colonial rule, he devoted only one paragraph to the "Irish question" by making an analogy between Irish-British and Korean-Japanese relations. Therefore his analogy is a very limited, and moreover, a forced one, since he makes the historically-false and pro-imperial statement that Korea voluntarily maintained a close economic and military relationship with Japan.
Yanaihara's articles on Korea in the 1920s strongly criticized the repressiveness of the Japanese colonial law and proposed the establishment of a colonial parliament. While his proposal was one of the most liberal, it contained several shortcomings. First, it was unrealistic, considering the weakness of the Japanese parliament itself. Second, he ignored the lesson learned from Irish history that showed that a colonial parliament could not solve colonial discontent.
Here the foundation of Yanaihara's analogy between Korea and Ireland crumbles, since in addition to, or because of, the strain it put on facts regarding the two countries. Therefore it did not lead to a better policy for Korea. When Yanaihara's views are brought up in conjunction with the statement that Korea and Ireland are similar, we must remember that his views are an artifact of the Japanese colonial era.
목차
Ⅰ. 머리말
Ⅱ. 야나이하라의 “아일랜드 문제“
Ⅲ. 조선통치론
Ⅳ. 아일랜드ㆍ조선ㆍ한국
〈Abstract〉
참고문헌 (0)
참고문헌 신청함께 읽어보면 좋을 논문
논문 유사도에 따라 DBpia 가 추천하는 논문입니다. 함께 보면 좋을 연관 논문을 확인해보세요!
-
야나이하라 다다오(矢内原忠雄)의 전후 평화론에 대한 일고찰
아시아문화연구
2017 .04
-
야나이하라 타다오(矢內原忠雄)의 식민정책론과 조선인식
대동문화연구
2004 .01
-
왜 <帝國主義下の朝鮮>은 없었는가? ― 야나이하라 타다오(矢內原忠雄)의 식민(정책)론과 대만･조선
史叢(사총)
2015 .01
-
An Ireland in Bloom: the Mythical Ireland Surviving in Ulysses
영어영문학연구
2007 .01
-
[번역문] 제국적 시선과 인문주의적 비평의 사이 : 일본식민지 담론과 타이완의 정체성 정치에 관한 사례 연구
로컬리티 인문학
2010 .10
-
아일랜드ㆍ인도의 민족운동과 한국의 자치운동 비교
역사학보
2004 .06
-
셰이머스 히니의 시에 나타난 탈식민주의 페미니즘
영어영문학연구
2003 .01
-
『캐슬린 니 훌리한』에서 아일랜드의 역사적 뿌리 찾기
한국 예이츠 저널
2018 .01
-
Place and Displacement in A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man
제임스조이스 저널
2008 .01
-
상처입은 아일랜드 아이의 복수—맥케이브의 『푸줏간 소년』
영어영문학21
2014 .01
-
근대 일본의 식민정책학에 나타난 조선인식
아시아문화연구
2012 .06
-
국민의 손님 - 아일랜드, 이주, 그리고 탈식민지 연대
흔적
2001 .12
-
Ethnicity and Truth in Yeats and Walcott: A Note from Ireland
한국 예이츠 저널
2012 .01
-
『조선(朝鮮)の특산(特産)』으로 보는 일제강점기 식품 특산물 현황 분석
한국식생활문화학회지
2019 .01
-
在朝鮮日本人浅川伯教 · 巧兄弟と柳宗悦の朝鮮伝統文化理解の特質 : 初期の活動を中心に
일본문화학보
2018 .11
-
브라이언 프리엘의 『몰리 스위니』 : 아일랜드의 과거와 현재 재조명하기
새한영어영문학
2003 .11
-
Samuel Beckett between “Europe” and “Ireland”
한국 예이츠 저널
2012 .01
-
재조일본인 교원의 조선체험 : 어느 사범학교교원의 사례
한국사연구
2011 .06
-
“켈트형 호랑이”: 아일랜드 경제 성장의 양상
영국 연구
2004 .01
이 논문의 저자 정보
이 논문과 함께 이용한 논문
아일랜드 대기근과 민족적 기억 : 톰 머피의 Famine 연구
홍유미
현대영미드라마
2008
.08
[역비논단] 1916년 부활절 봉기, 아일랜드 민족운동의 전환점
최재희
역사비평
2004
.05
아일랜드 역사서술 : 민족주의와 수정주의를 넘어서
박지향
역사비평
2000
.02
근대 일본의 식민정책학에 나타난 조선인식
이규수
아시아문화연구
2012
.06
[번역문] 제국적 시선과 인문주의적 비평의 사이 : 일본식민지 담론과 타이완의 정체성 정치에 관한 사례 연구
Lung-Chih Chang
,
하명자
로컬리티 인문학
2010
.10
최근 본 자료
댓글(0)
0
UCI(KEPA) : I410-ECN-0101-2010-911-002858350