메뉴 건너뛰기
.. 내서재 .. 알림
소속 기관/학교 인증
인증하면 논문, 학술자료 등을  무료로 열람할 수 있어요.
한국대학교, 누리자동차, 시립도서관 등 나의 기관을 확인해보세요
(국내 대학 90% 이상 구독 중)
로그인 회원가입 고객센터 ENG
주제분류
인문학
인문학 일반 역사학 철학 종교학 어문학 기타 인문학
사회과학
사회과학 일반 경영학 관광학 교육학 군사학 문헌정보학 법학 사회학 신문방송학 심리과학 정치외교학 지리학 행정학 경제학 무역학 인류학 기타 사회과학
자연과학
자연과학 일반 물리학 생물학 생활과학 수학·통계학 천문학 지구과학 화학 기타 자연과학
공학
공학 일반 건축공학 기계공학 산업공학 재료·에너지공학 전기전자공학 조선해양공학 화학공학 컴퓨터학 기타공학
의약학
의학 일반 간호학 수의학 약학 한의학 기초의학 임상의학 기타 의약학
농수해양학
농수해양학 일반 농학 수산학 식품과학 임학 축산학 해상운송학 기타 농수해양학
예술체육학
예술 일반 디자인 미술 미용 사진 음악학 의상 체육 공연매체예술 기타 예술체육학
복합학
학제간연구 과학기술학 뇌인지과학 기술정책 기타 복합학

ENG

추천
검색

논문 기본 정보

자료유형
학술저널
저자정보
Seong-Gon Kim (Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, College of Dentistry, Gangneung-Wonju National Univer)
저널정보
대한악안면성형재건외과학회 Maxillofacial Plastic Reconstructive Surgery Maxillofacial Plastic Reconstructive Surgery 제43권
발행연도
2021.12
수록면
1 - 2 (2page)
DOI
10.1186/s40902-021-00321-7

이용수

표지
📌
연구주제
📖
연구배경
🔬
연구방법
🏆
연구결과
AI에게 요청하기
추천
검색

초록· 키워드

오류제보하기
The main task of scientific journals is publishing highlyimpactful articles in their field. However, publishing isnot free. Financial pressure can be found from the operating submission system, article review process, editingthe accepted articles, etc. The classic article has asubscription-based model, which readers pay to view. Although large companies save money by distributinglabor-intensive work to the low- and middle-incomecountries, small regional publishers cannot endure thisincrease in publication fees. Accordingly, except for afew publishers, most publishers select an open-accessmodel as their publication model. Now, only rich peoplecan submit their work for publication to a scientificjournal. At a glance, this is not fair; a big company givesa waiver for a submission from underdeveloped countries. While this is fine, the number of submissions fromthese countries is limited and the general quality of articles is not good enough. Thus, most editors still rely onsubmissions from qualified scientists, but not all of thesescientists are rich. Accordingly, the article processingcharge (APC) should be paid by public funds, universities, or academic societies. Otherwise, these parties willnot have a chance for publication. The article indexing service shows its power at thispoint. In the case of Korea, most universities support theAPC only for articles published in Scientific CitationIndex Expanded (SCIE) journals (operated by ClarivateAnalytics). Some universities also pay for the articlesindexed by Scopus (operated by Elsevier). Therefore, theeditor should try their best to index their journal to oneof these services. Otherwise, the number of submissionswill not increase. As the importance of indexing increases, the transparency of selecting criteria is also important for maintaining the authority of the indexingservices. Three years ago, the following reason for rejection was suggested by a famous indexing service: “It is agreat pity that the society was advised to drop the wordKorean from the title, as this gave the journal a veryclear geographic distinction and discriminator fromother journals, which it has now lost.” Even though weremoved “Korean” from the title, I do not believe thisdecision damaged the quality of our journal. If this is themain reason for rejection, we will not have a secondchance until correcting our journal title. This can be evidence that politics intervened in this decision process,even in major indexing services. In the case of ClarivateAnalytics, the service did not communicate with the editor, who is mainly responsible for the quality control ofthe journal. Although Maxillofacial Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery (MPRS) has been indexed by the Emerging Sources Citation Index (ESCI), I have not receiveda single mail from Clarivate Analytics for the background of this decision. If the editor does not know theweakness of their journal, there will be no way to improve the journal. Recently, Clarivate Analytics launched the “JournalCitation Indicator (JCI)” for evaluating both SCIE andESCI titles. It looks like a wonderful trial and can be thefirst step for a fair comparison among titles. Fair competition should not be the motto exclusively for the sportsgame only. Some titles have extremely low impact, butstill, stay in the SCIE. Without political consideration,this is poorly explained. Most major indexing servicesasked for a new journal to be included as the first or thesecond quartiles (Q1 or Q2) in terms of citations. However, it is unclear whether it should be positioned justonce or should be positioned serially. There has been upand down in the citation number of indexed journals. Ifonly new born journals should keep their status as Q1or Q2, it should be unfair. According to JCI, MPRS hasbeen ranked 62nd in 2019 and the 80th in 2020 amongthe category of the Dentistry, Oral Surgery & Medicine.

목차

등록된 정보가 없습니다.

참고문헌 (0)

참고문헌 신청
참고문헌이 DBpia에서 서비스 중이라면, [참고문헌 신청]을 통해 등록해보세요

함께 읽어보면 좋을 논문

논문 유사도에 따라 DBpia 가 추천하는 논문입니다. 함께 보면 좋을 연관 논문을 확인해보세요!

이 논문의 저자 정보

최근 본 자료

전체보기

댓글(0)

0